Advertisements for Catholic Mass removed after request for Full Moon Ceremony

Third level colleges across the country are continuing to deal with the outcome of a successful Atheist Ireland campaign with respect to their State-funded chaplaincies. That campaign resulted in a report being issued by the Higher Education Authority, which required all chaplaincies funded by public monies in third level colleges, to strictly adhere to their constitutional obligations with respect to religious discrimination. Colleges are now realising that this means they cannot privilege Roman Catholic students, over students of other faiths and none. Most recently, Dundalk IT has removed advertisements for Roman Catholic Mass from its web site. The removal followed a request from an Ard Druí at the Celtic Druid Temple to also arrange a Full Moon Ceremony in the chaplaincy “Chapel/Prayer Room”, and to advertise this ceremony in exactly the same manner as their Roman Catholic Mass was advertised.

Article 44.2.2 of the Irish Constitution states that:

The State guarantees not to endow any religion.

Atheist Ireland has previously highlighted the behaviour of many third level colleges in handing large sums of public money to Roman Catholic bishops in secret, without advertisement or tender, so that the Catholic Church would assign a priest to provide chaplaincy services. This activity was costing the State more than €1.5M per annum and Atheist Ireland argued that this is inconsistent with Article 44.2.2. Like other third level colleges, Dundalk IT issued a public tender following this HEA report and the chaplain was re-appointed at a significantly reduced cost to public funds. However, Article 44.2.3 of the Irish Constitution also states that:

The State shall not impose any disabilities or make any discrimination on the ground of religion or religious profession, belief of status.

In fact, as is illustrated below in the conclusions of the HEA report, colleges are specifically reminded of their constitutional responsibility to make chaplaincy services available to “students of all faiths” without any discrimination between them.

 

Conclusions from HEA Report

Conclusions from HEA Report

 

Previously, Dundalk IT had advertised on the college web site, that regular Roman Catholic Mass would be provided in the “Chapel/Prayer Room” at the college chaplaincy. That advertisement is illustrated in the image below, but visiting the same web page now shows that the college has removed their advertisement for Roman Catholic Mass.

The removal of the advertisement for Roman Catholic Mass on the campus, followed a request from an Ard Druí at the Celtic Druid Temple. The request was for a Full Moon Ceremony to be conducted by an Ard Druí in the same campus “Chapel/Prayer Room” as the Roman Catholic Mass, and that the Full Moon Ceremony should be advertised by the college in exactly the same manner as the Roman Catholic Mass had been advertised. Rather than accept or reject this request to treat this of all faiths and none equally, the college has simply decided to remove their advertisement for Roman Catholic Mass on campus.

 

Previous Dundalk IT Chaplaincy Web Site

Previous Dundalk IT Chaplaincy Web Site

 

This situation leaves a number of questions unanswered though. For example, will some colleges continue to provide facilities exclusively for Roman Catholic activities to the exclusion of those from other faiths and none, even if the Roman Catholic activities will no longer be advertised? At the time of writing, Dundalk IT has still not answered this question. More broadly, considering the third level sector as a whole, will State-funded Roman Catholic chaplains be using their time in our universities and colleges to preach the Catholic position on abortion during the referendum campaign? What will the position of our universities and colleges be on this issue, considering their constitutional obligations as outlined to them by the HEA?

John Hamill

3 Comments

  1. Avatar
    Vivienne Daly March 19, 2018

    Brilliant!

  2. Avatar
    Alan March 21, 2018

    While I agree with main argument here, in the upholding and the defense of the constitutional articles, nevertheless, the point remains that, ‘Druidism’ seems to be, at best, a nature based, non dogmatic, ‘spirituality’ and should not be elevated to a class of ‘religion’ and of course, Atheism, is not a religion either. Therefore, whilst the college seems to have made the correct decision here, in my humble opinion, the ‘victory’ lies in the actual, respective constitutional articles and not in any religion!

    • Avatar
      John Hamill April 16, 2018

      Hi Alan … the General Registrar’s Office maintains a list of recognised religious bodies in Ireland for the purpose of wedding solemnisation. The Celtic Druid Temple is on the list. As far as the Irish State is concerned, Druidism is every bit as much a religion as Catholicism. I guess Druids have been practising their religion in Ireland long before people showed up talking about some carpenter-god from thousands of miles away. 🙂 Out of interest, would you consider Buddhism to be a religion? On their web site the Dublin Buddhist Centre states that they don’t believe in a god and so this is an atheist religion (Jainism is another atheist religion). The Dublin Buddhist Centre is also registered as a religious body at the GRO. I don’t think it is within the gift of Irish third level colleges to make subjective decisions about what is and isn’t a “real” religion.

Atheist Ireland